ExtraMenus.cpp not link dependent on external sub-menu definitions...

... They use the registry

src/Menus.cpp

@@ -976,6 +976,12 @@ void InitializeMenuOrdering()
       {wxT(""), wxT(
 "File,Edit,Select,View,Transport,Tracks,Generate,Effect,Analyze,Tools,Window,Optional,Help"
        )},
+      {wxT("/Optional/Extra/Part1"), wxT(
+"Transport,Tools,Mixer,Edit,PlayAtSpeed,Seek,Device,Select"
+       )},
+      {wxT("/Optional/Extra/Part2"), wxT(
+"Navigation,Focus,Cursor,Track,Scriptables1,Scriptables2"
+       )},
       {wxT("/View/Windows"), wxT("UndoHistory,Karaoke,MixerBoard")},
       {wxT("/Analyze/Analyzers/Windows"), wxT("ContrastAnalyser,PlotSpectrum")},
    };

src/menus/ClipMenus.cpp

@@ -871,7 +871,7 @@ MenuTable::BaseItemSharedPtr ClipCursorItems()
    return items;
 }
 
-// Under /MenuBar/Optional/Extra/Cursor
+// Under /MenuBar/Optional/Extra/Part2/Cursor
 MenuTable::BaseItemSharedPtr ExtraClipCursorItems()
 {
    using namespace MenuTable;

src/menus/EditMenus.cpp

@@ -1168,10 +1168,8 @@ AttachedItem sAttachment1{
    wxT(""),
    Shared( EditMenu() )
 };
-}
 
-// Under /MenuBar/Optional/Extra
-MenuTable::BaseItemSharedPtr ExtraEditMenu()
+BaseItemSharedPtr ExtraEditMenu()
 {
    using Options = CommandManager::Options;
    static const auto flags =
@@ -1227,4 +1225,10 @@ RegisteredMenuItemEnabler selectWaveTracks2{{
    selectAll
 }};
 
+AttachedItem sAttachment2{
+   wxT("Optional/Extra/Part1"),
+   Shared( ExtraEditMenu() )
+};
+
+}
 #undef FN

src/menus/ExtraMenus.cpp

@@ -136,28 +136,11 @@ static CommandHandlerObject &findCommandHandler(AudacityProject &) {
 
 #define FN(X) (& ExtraActions::Handler :: X)
 
-// Imported menu item definitions
-
-MenuTable::BaseItemSharedPtr ExtraEditMenu();
-MenuTable::BaseItemSharedPtr ExtraSelectionMenu();
-MenuTable::BaseItemSharedPtr ExtraCursorMenu();
-MenuTable::BaseItemSharedPtr ExtraSeekMenu();
-MenuTable::BaseItemSharedPtr ExtraToolsMenu();
-MenuTable::BaseItemSharedPtr ExtraTransportMenu();
-MenuTable::BaseItemSharedPtr ExtraPlayAtSpeedMenu();
-MenuTable::BaseItemSharedPtr ExtraTrackMenu();
-MenuTable::BaseItemSharedPtr ExtraScriptablesIMenu();
-MenuTable::BaseItemSharedPtr ExtraScriptablesIIMenu();
-MenuTable::BaseItemSharedPtr ExtraWindowItems();
-MenuTable::BaseItemSharedPtr ExtraGlobalCommands();
-MenuTable::BaseItemSharedPtr ExtraFocusMenu();
-
 namespace {
 using namespace MenuTable;
 
 BaseItemSharedPtr ExtraMixerMenu();
 BaseItemSharedPtr ExtraDeviceMenu();
-BaseItemPtr ExtraMiscItems( AudacityProject & );
 
 BaseItemSharedPtr ExtraMenu()
 {
@@ -165,27 +148,11 @@ BaseItemSharedPtr ExtraMenu()
    // TODO:  devise a registration system instead.
    static BaseItemSharedPtr extraItems{ Items( wxEmptyString,
       Section( "Part1",
-           ExtraTransportMenu()
-         , ExtraToolsMenu()
-         , ExtraMixerMenu()
-         , ExtraEditMenu()
-         , ExtraPlayAtSpeedMenu()
-         , ExtraSeekMenu()
+           ExtraMixerMenu()
          , ExtraDeviceMenu()
-         , ExtraSelectionMenu()
       ),
 
-      Section( "Part2",
-           ExtraGlobalCommands()
-         , ExtraFocusMenu()
-         , ExtraCursorMenu()
-         , ExtraTrackMenu()
-         , ExtraScriptablesIMenu()
-         , ExtraScriptablesIIMenu()
-
-         // Delayed evaluation:
-         , ExtraMiscItems
-      )
+      Section( "Part2" )
    ) };
 
    static const auto pred =
@@ -202,7 +169,7 @@ AttachedItem sAttachment1{
    Shared( ExtraMenu() )
 };
 
-// Under /MenuBar/Optional/Extra
+// Under /MenuBar/Optional/Extra/Part1
 BaseItemSharedPtr ExtraMixerMenu()
 {
    static BaseItemSharedPtr menu{
@@ -224,7 +191,7 @@ BaseItemSharedPtr ExtraMixerMenu()
    return menu;
 }
 
-// Under /MenuBar/Optional/Extra
+// Under /MenuBar/Optional/Extra/Part1
 BaseItemSharedPtr ExtraDeviceMenu()
 {
    static BaseItemSharedPtr menu{
@@ -245,8 +212,8 @@ BaseItemSharedPtr ExtraDeviceMenu()
    return menu;
 }
 
-// Under /MenuBar/Optional/Extra
-BaseItemPtr ExtraMiscItems( AudacityProject &project )
+// Under /MenuBar/Optional/Extra/Part2
+BaseItemPtr ExtraMiscItems()
 {
    using Options = CommandManager::Options;
 
@@ -261,17 +228,24 @@ BaseItemPtr ExtraMiscItems( AudacityProject &project )
    // Not a menu.
    return ( FinderScope{ findCommandHandler },
    Items( wxT("Misc"),
+      // Delayed evaluation
+      []( AudacityProject &project ) {
+         return
          // Accel key is not bindable.
          Command( wxT("FullScreenOnOff"), XXO("&Full Screen (on/off)"),
             FN(OnFullScreen),
             AlwaysEnabledFlag,
             Options{ key }.CheckState(
-            GetProjectFrame( project ).wxTopLevelWindow::IsFullScreen() ) ),
-
-      ExtraWindowItems()
+               GetProjectFrame( project ).wxTopLevelWindow::IsFullScreen() ) );
+      }
    ) );
 }
 
+AttachedItem sAttachment2{
+   Placement{ wxT("Optional/Extra/Part2"), { OrderingHint::End } },
+   Shared( ExtraMiscItems() )
+};
+
 }
 
 #undef FN

src/menus/NavigationMenus.cpp

@@ -555,11 +555,11 @@ static CommandHandlerObject &findCommandHandler(AudacityProject &project) {
 
 #define FN(X) (& NavigationActions::Handler :: X)
 
-// Under /MenuBar/Optional/Extra
-MenuTable::BaseItemSharedPtr ExtraGlobalCommands()
+namespace {
+using namespace MenuTable;
+BaseItemSharedPtr ExtraGlobalCommands()
 {
    // Ceci n'est pas un menu
-   using namespace MenuTable;
    using Options = CommandManager::Options;
 
    static BaseItemSharedPtr items{
@@ -575,10 +575,13 @@ MenuTable::BaseItemSharedPtr ExtraGlobalCommands()
    return items;
 }
 
-// Under /MenuBar/Optional/Extra
-MenuTable::BaseItemSharedPtr ExtraFocusMenu()
+AttachedItem sAttachment2{
+   wxT("Optional/Extra/Part2"),
+   Shared( ExtraGlobalCommands() )
+};
+
+BaseItemSharedPtr ExtraFocusMenu()
 {
-   using namespace MenuTable;
    static const auto FocusedTracksFlags = TracksExistFlag() | TrackPanelHasFocus();
 
    static BaseItemSharedPtr menu{
@@ -610,4 +613,11 @@ MenuTable::BaseItemSharedPtr ExtraFocusMenu()
    return menu;
 }
 
+AttachedItem sAttachment3{
+   wxT("Optional/Extra/Part2"),
+   Shared( ExtraFocusMenu() )
+};
+
+}
+
 #undef FN

src/menus/PluginMenus.cpp

@@ -917,10 +917,8 @@ AttachedItem sAttachment4{
    wxT(""),
    Shared( ToolsMenu() )
 };
-}
 
-// Under /MenuBar/Optional/Extra
-MenuTable::BaseItemSharedPtr ExtraScriptablesIMenu()
+BaseItemSharedPtr ExtraScriptablesIMenu()
 {
    // These are the more useful to VI user Scriptables.
    static BaseItemSharedPtr menu{
@@ -967,8 +965,12 @@ MenuTable::BaseItemSharedPtr ExtraScriptablesIMenu()
    return menu;
 }
 
-// Under /MenuBar/Optional/Extra
-MenuTable::BaseItemSharedPtr ExtraScriptablesIIMenu()
+AttachedItem sAttachment5{
+   wxT("Optional/Extra/Part2"),
+   Shared( ExtraScriptablesIMenu() )
+};
+
+BaseItemSharedPtr ExtraScriptablesIIMenu()
 {
    // Less useful to VI users.
    static BaseItemSharedPtr menu{
@@ -1007,4 +1009,11 @@ MenuTable::BaseItemSharedPtr ExtraScriptablesIIMenu()
    return menu;
 }
 
+AttachedItem sAttachment6{
+   wxT("Optional/Extra/Part2"),
+   Shared( ExtraScriptablesIIMenu() )
+};
+
+}
+
 #undef FN

src/menus/SelectMenus.cpp

@@ -1148,10 +1148,8 @@ AttachedItem sAttachment1{
    wxT(""),
    Shared( SelectMenu() )
 };
-}
 
-// Under /MenuBar/Optional/Extra
-MenuTable::BaseItemSharedPtr ExtraSelectionMenu()
+BaseItemSharedPtr ExtraSelectionMenu()
 {
    static BaseItemSharedPtr menu{
    ( FinderScope{ findCommandHandler },
@@ -1192,6 +1190,12 @@ MenuTable::BaseItemSharedPtr ExtraSelectionMenu()
    return menu;
 }
 
+AttachedItem sAttachment2{
+   wxT("Optional/Extra/Part1"),
+   Shared( ExtraSelectionMenu() )
+};
+}
+
 MenuTable::BaseItemSharedPtr ClipCursorItems();
 
 // Under /MenuBar/Transport
@@ -1241,8 +1245,8 @@ MenuTable::BaseItemSharedPtr CursorMenu()
 
 MenuTable::BaseItemSharedPtr ExtraClipCursorItems();
 
-// Under /MenuBar/Optional/Extra
-MenuTable::BaseItemSharedPtr ExtraCursorMenu()
+namespace {
+BaseItemSharedPtr ExtraCursorMenu()
 {
    static BaseItemSharedPtr menu{
    ( FinderScope{ findCommandHandler },
@@ -1271,8 +1275,12 @@ MenuTable::BaseItemSharedPtr ExtraCursorMenu()
    return menu;
 }
 
-// Under /MenuBar/Optional/Extra
-MenuTable::BaseItemSharedPtr ExtraSeekMenu()
+AttachedItem sAttachment4{
+   wxT("Optional/Extra/Part2"),
+   Shared( ExtraCursorMenu() )
+};
+
+BaseItemSharedPtr ExtraSeekMenu()
 {
    static BaseItemSharedPtr menu{
    ( FinderScope{ findCommandHandler },
@@ -1290,4 +1298,11 @@ MenuTable::BaseItemSharedPtr ExtraSeekMenu()
    return menu;
 }
 
+AttachedItem sAttachment5{
+   wxT("Optional/Extra/Part1"),
+   Shared( ExtraSeekMenu() )
+};
+
+}
+
 #undef FN

src/menus/ToolbarMenus.cpp

@@ -338,10 +338,10 @@ MenuTable::BaseItemSharedPtr ToolbarsMenu()
    return menu;
 }
 
-// Under /MenuBar/Optional/Extra
-MenuTable::BaseItemSharedPtr ExtraToolsMenu()
-{
+namespace {
 using namespace MenuTable;
+BaseItemSharedPtr ExtraToolsMenu()
+{
    static BaseItemSharedPtr menu{
    ( FinderScope{ findCommandHandler },
    Menu( wxT("Tools"), XO("T&ools"),
@@ -365,4 +365,10 @@ MenuTable::BaseItemSharedPtr ExtraToolsMenu()
    return menu;
 }
 
+AttachedItem sAttachment2{
+   wxT("Optional/Extra/Part1"),
+   Shared( ExtraToolsMenu() )
+};
+}
+
 #undef FN

src/menus/TrackMenus.cpp

@@ -1442,10 +1442,8 @@ AttachedItem sAttachment1{
    wxT(""),
    Shared( TracksMenu() )
 };
-}
 
-// Under /MenuBar/Optional/Extra
-MenuTable::BaseItemSharedPtr ExtraTrackMenu()
+BaseItemSharedPtr ExtraTrackMenu()
 {
    static BaseItemSharedPtr menu{
    ( FinderScope{ findCommandHandler },
@@ -1497,4 +1495,11 @@ MenuTable::BaseItemSharedPtr ExtraTrackMenu()
    return menu;
 }
 
+AttachedItem sAttachment2{
+   wxT("Optional/Extra/Part2"),
+   Shared( ExtraTrackMenu() )
+};
+
+}
+
 #undef FN

src/menus/TransportMenus.cpp

@@ -1103,10 +1103,8 @@ AttachedItem sAttachment1{
    wxT(""),
    Shared( TransportMenu() )
 };
-}
 
-// Under /MenuBar/Optional/Extra
-MenuTable::BaseItemSharedPtr ExtraTransportMenu()
+BaseItemSharedPtr ExtraTransportMenu()
 {
    static BaseItemSharedPtr menu{
    ( FinderScope{ findCommandHandler },
@@ -1156,8 +1154,12 @@ MenuTable::BaseItemSharedPtr ExtraTransportMenu()
    return menu;
 }
 
-// Under /MenuBar/Optional/Extra
-MenuTable::BaseItemSharedPtr ExtraPlayAtSpeedMenu()
+AttachedItem sAttachment2{
+   wxT("Optional/Extra/Part1"),
+   Shared( ExtraTransportMenu() )
+};
+
+BaseItemSharedPtr ExtraPlayAtSpeedMenu()
 {
    static BaseItemSharedPtr menu{
    ( FinderScope{ findCommandHandler },
@@ -1189,4 +1191,11 @@ MenuTable::BaseItemSharedPtr ExtraPlayAtSpeedMenu()
    return menu;
 }
 
+AttachedItem sAttachment3{
+   wxT("Optional/Extra/Part1"),
+   Shared( ExtraPlayAtSpeedMenu() )
+};
+
+}
+
 #undef FN

src/menus/WindowMenus.cpp

@@ -154,10 +154,7 @@ AttachedItem sAttachment1{
    Shared( WindowMenu() )
 };
 
-}
-
-// Under /MenuBar/Optional/Extra/Misc
-MenuTable::BaseItemSharedPtr ExtraWindowItems()
+BaseItemSharedPtr ExtraWindowItems()
 {
    static BaseItemSharedPtr items{
    ( FinderScope{ findCommandHandler },
@@ -171,14 +168,17 @@ MenuTable::BaseItemSharedPtr ExtraWindowItems()
    return items;
 }
 
+AttachedItem sAttachment2{
+   Placement{ wxT("Optional/Extra/Part2/Misc"), OrderingHint::End },
+   Shared( ExtraWindowItems() )
+};
+
+}
+
 #undef FN
 
 #else
 
-// Not WXMAC.  Stub functions.
-MenuTable::BaseItemSharedPtr ExtraWindowItems()
-{
-   return nullptr;
-}
+// Not WXMAC.
 
 #endif